Skip to content

John’s Horror Corner: The Thing (2011)…that shouldn’t have been remade

March 16, 2013

MY CALL:  This was a solidly entertaining, effects-driven sci-fi thriller/action movie.  I’ll certainly buy it on Blu-Ray.  But don’t think for a moment that it compares to the original.  When I try NOT to compare it to the 1982 original, I give it a B/B-.  I won’t lie, though.  While entertained, I was disappointed.

WARNING:  Please do not dare watch this until you’ve seen the original first.  FIRST!  I don’t care if this is a prequel.  The 1982 version still holds up strongly and Kurt Russell and the old gang deliver what NO ONE in this new installment can.  Watching this prequel first may completely ruin a much better movie for you altogether.  Don’t tell yourself that a 1982 movie couldn’t possibly entertain you as much as a 2011 movie.  It may be hard to believe, but you’d be wrong.

We’ll start by ignoring the AMAZING quality of the 1982 predecessor…

So some scientists find a block of ice with some “thing” in it.

They thaw it out and…

Hey, wait a minute!  Does this feel familiar?

Yes!  Yes it does.  This scene happened in 1982!

This new movie was very entertaining and I really enjoyed the effects.  The Thing’s “thing” was reminiscent of a monster from the Resident Evil movies—in a good way.  It was fast, anime-tendril-rich, polymorphic, voracious and disgusting, all delivered with a CGI report card of straight A’s.  Fans of the macabre will adore the transformation scenes.

The big flaw was that I couldn’t have cared less about the characters.  I mean, Warrior’s Joel Edgerton should be easy to root for, and the director clearly tried to make him a Kurt Russell MacReady clone, yet I didn’t even care if he lived.  They added a chick scientist to the mix, too: Scream Queen Mary Elizabeth Winstead (Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter).  But that didn’t imrove things for me either.  I think the problem was that there was not enough nerve-wracking suspense and the dialogue was uncompelling.  The suspense SHOULD make me wonder what will happen to you characters.  The quality of your lines decides whether or not I CARE what happens to you.

It may have been a prequel, but it masquerades as a remake.  The characters have different names, but many of them look stunningly similar to their doppelganger-counterparts in the 1982 original and even find themselves in scenes that are obviously modeled, honestly more blatantly remade, from the original.


Like Kurt Russell, a red-bearded fellow and another ginger scientist in 1982; Joel Edgerton with his red-bearded Norseman and ginger scientist in 2011.

Russell’s MacCready and close ally in 1982.
MacCready look-alike Edgerton and his bestie in 2011.

I don’t mean to go all Jekyll and Hyde on you, but now let’s shift gears and bask in our beautiful memories of the 1982 original.  It didn’t rely on action.  It was suspense-driven.  When action did show its face the monstrous transformations were slow and horrific; difficult to watch for some, much like the transformations in An American Werewolf in London and In the Company of Wolves.

This movie attempted to ruin breasts for me.

I can’t help but to wonder if the simplicity of CGI monster-action led to the director simply drop the ball on the suspense and terror in the 2011 installment.  I really never had that classic The Thing mood during this new one.  Even the scene where they try to “test” who’s infected lacks intensity.  When I watch the original, I FEEL it!

Not feelin’ it, 2011.
Totally feelin’ it, 1982!

Remakes and prequels don’t have to match the style of the original, but they should bring something to the table to make it its own—like the switch from the suspense-driven Alien to the action-driven Aliens, very different, but they nailed it with each respective style.  This prequel didn’t nail it.  The effects were fun and Fangoria probably got a good article out of it, but don’t see this movie because you loved the 1982 original.  See it because you want to see the latest CGI-action sci-fi flick.

The most unfortunate thing about 2011’s The Thing was that this movie, as a prequel, ruins the 1982 sequel for anyone who hasn’t seen it yet.  So many of the scenes use 1982’s playbook that you may immediately recognize them.  These two movies are meant to show us what happened at two different sites with two different sets of characters.  Yet, were it not for the last scene of the prequel and the first scene of the original/sequel, you’d never know this wasn’t just a modern reimagining.

I realize this sounds like a muck-raking convention.  It’s just hard to say anything positive other than “the effects were great and the gore was a lot of fun”.  I enjoyed it.  I REALLY did.  I’ll even buy it…but I’ll always call it the red-headed stepchild of the 1982 sequel, which oozed eerie mood and intensity.

One final note:  I would advise that no one ever see the “true” original The Thing from Another World (1951).  It would only disappoint.

41 Comments leave one →
  1. Papa Ratchet permalink
    October 28, 2014 8:11 am

    “How can a 1982 movie entertain me more than a 2011 movie?” That was kinda stupid, considering all forms of media, movies, tv and music especially, are garbage in this day in time. Old Skool FTW!!

    • johnleavengood permalink
      October 29, 2014 8:58 am

      The old school horror troupe NEEDED to make effects and creepiness work back before greater budgets were invested in perfectly timed scores for mood elevation and CGI to solve all of their problems and FX woes. FTW indeed!


  1. John’s Horror Corner [INDEX] | Movies, Films & Flix
  2. The Best Horror Came from the 80s: Horror movies that stand the Test of Time and their more modern counterparts, Part 1 | Movies, Films & Flix
  3. Black Christmas (2006), a prime example of how exposition truly is the death of horror…that, and lousy remakes | Movies, Films & Flix
  4. John’s Horror Corner: The Boneyard (1991), it’s not your average hulking, evil, mutant zombie poodle movie | Movies, Films & Flix
  5. John’s Old School Horror Corner: Forbidden World (1982) | Movies, Films & Flix
  6. John’s Horror Corner presents Strong Opinions: on the Poltergeist remake | Movies, Films & Flix
  7. John’s Old School Horror Corner: Creepozoids (1987), yet another low budget 80s Alien rip-off | Movies, Films & Flix
  8. » Movie Review – Thing, The (2011) Fernby Films
  9. John’s Horror Corner: The Stuff (1985), a social commentary told by a mind-controlling dessert food | Movies, Films & Flix
  10. Carrie (2013), a worthy remake that should stoke interest in the original | Movies, Films & Flix
  11. John’s Old School Horror Corner: They Live (1988), featuring bubble gum, kicking ass, cheese dip and corporate alien takeovers | Movies, Films & Flix
  12. HORROR TRAILER TALK: The Thing goes National Geographic, non-Zombies, contemporized Werewolves, Satanic Cults, ill-fated flights and Aliens behaving badly | Movies, Films & Flix
  13. John’s Horror Corner: Blood Glacier (2013), and what Al Gore wanted you to think would happen as a result of global warming…and the inconvenient truth of mutant monster animals!!! | Movies, Films & Flix
  14. The TOP 10 Survivors of Horror | Movies, Films & Flix
  15. John’s Horror Corner presents Strong Opinions: on the Poltergeist (2015) remake, a second opinion now that we have producer Sam Raimi and a trailer to comfort us | Movies, Films & Flix
  16. John’s Horror Corner: Extraterrestrial (2014), a playful approach to gory sci-fi horror that samples a little of everything. | Movies, Films & Flix
  17. John’s Horror Corner: Bio Slime (2010), a budgetless, sleazy, slimy tentacle monster movie that makes a valiant effort with its creature effects. | Movies, Films & Flix
  18. John’s Horror Corner: Harbinger Down (2015), the entertaining yet lackluster mutant monster lovechild of The Thing (1982) and Leviathan (1989). | Movies, Films & Flix
  19. John’s Horror Corner: Blair Witch (2016), discussing a divisive franchise whose third installment offered nothing new except LOUD NOISES and a videogame monster. | Movies, Films & Flix
  20. John’s Horror Corner: Night of the Demons 2 (1994), yet more boobs, more gore, more lipstick, and more fun cheesy demonic possession than part 1. | Movies, Films & Flix
  21. John’s Horror Corner: Metamorphosis: The Alien Factor (1990), a gory callback to The Thing (1982) complete with mutant alien parasites and gooey transformations. | Movies, Films & Flix
  22. John’s Horror Corner: The Void (2016), the indie horror where The Thing’s (1982) practical effects meet Lovecraft and Barker! | Movies, Films & Flix
  23. John’s Horror Corner presents Strong Opinions: Critically analyzing 10 reasons I appreciated the Evil Dead (2013) remake. | Movies, Films & Flix
  24. John’s Horror Corner: Fright Night (2011), reflecting on the 1985 original through the lens of a remake. | Movies, Films & Flix
  25. John’s Horror Corner: Stephen King’s It (2017), a worthy re-adaptation and R-rated remake of 1990’s TV-PG Pennywise. | Movies, Films & Flix
  26. 15 Images for 15 Years of Horror, Part 4 (2003-2017): some of the greatest, goriest, most shocking and most memorably defining moments in horror | Movies, Films & Flix
  27. John’s Horror Corner: The Town That Dreaded Sundown (2014), a meta-sequel remake of the seminal slasher classic. | Movies, Films & Flix
  28. John’s Horror Corner: Suspiria (2018), a stylish yet retro-chic remake of Argento’s Italian classic about a witch coven nested in a German ballet academy. | Movies, Films & Flix
  29. John’s Horror Corner: It’s Alive (2009), a gory over-the-top “baby horror” remake. | Movies, Films & Flix
  30. Love, Death & Robots (2019), the animated Sci-Fi anthology series I’ve waited my whole life to see! | Movies, Films & Flix
  31. John’s Horror Corner: Splinter (2008), delivering twitchy plant zombies and outstandingly gory practical creature effects. | Movies, Films & Flix
  32. John’s Horror Corner: The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003), a worthy remake bringing new levels of meanness to the franchise. | Movies, Films & Flix
  33. John’s Horror Corner: Friday the 13th (2009), a remake/requel love letter to the early 80s featuring brutally familiar death scenes. | Movies, Films & Flix
  34. John’s Horror Corner: Maniac (2012), a brutal remake of a slasher classic, and starring Elijah Wood. | Movies, Films & Flix
  35. John’s Horror Corner: Child’s Play (2019), the fun reboot of the 1988 classic evil doll franchise that we deserve! | Movies, Films & Flix
  36. John’s Horror Corner: Patrick: Evil Awakens (2013), a mediocre medical-mystery horror remake of the 1978 classic. | Movies, Films & Flix
  37. John’s Horror Corner: The Grudge (2004), the suspenseful remake of the Japanese Ju-on: The Grudge (2002). | Movies, Films & Flix
  38. John’s Horror Corner: Unhinged (2017), an equally lame remake of the forgettable 1982 exploitation slasher film. | Movies, Films & Flix
  39. John’s Horror Corner: Rabid (2019), the Soska sisters’ more monstrous remake of David Cronenberg’s 1977 classic. | Movies, Films & Flix

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: